Content Marketing vs. Content Strategy

At the risk of getting Inside Baseball on you, I want to call out something first brought to my attention in the most recent episode of “PNR: This Old Marketing.” That something is a debate by the show’s hosts Joe Pulizzi and Robert Rose over the meanings of “content marketing” vs. “content strategy,” inspired by the use of these terms in a new free online class from Northwestern University on content strategy.

Sadly, the Northwestern class, like too many people in my profession, uses the terms interchangeably. As Joe and Robert correctly explain (in the last 10 min. of the show, starting at 42:00), the distinction is subtle, but it’s important not to use these terms interchangeably. They do have separate, widely (mis)understood meanings.

Content strategy vs. content marketing
Though these terms are abstract, I’m going to try make them easy to digest. Content strategy is generally more about plotting the entire user experience, information architecture, and utility of content. Content marketing, on the other hand, represents the creation and placement/promotion (i.e., marketing) of specific content, usually of the instructive, helpful type that does not directly promote a product/service.

For example, company websites are often designed according to a content strategy based on the goals of its various audiences. The specific output companies produce (quintessential example: Red Bull) and promote on their websites and elsewhere could be examples of content marketing.  As long as the goal is to interest, educate or guide customers without a product-focused or hard-sell approach, you could probably call it content marketing—at least under its broadest definition. However, any great content that is not easily accessible fails from a business perspective. How?

“Useful, usable and desirable”
The key word that defines content strategy (apart from its marketing sister) is “usable.” My old college classmate and fellow marketing comrade DJ Francis puts it best in a video (above) where he brilliantly describes content strategy with Post-it notes as the forward-looking creation of “useful, usable and desirable” content alongside the design and architecture to support it. In other words, true content strategy suggests content is not just something to toss in on top of a design, but rather, central to its very creation. The content informs the design, or at least develops alongside it, not stamped on as an afterthought. In this sense, the “usability” is integral to the difference between these two terms, because content strategy as a discipline concerns itself broadly with the user experience and users’ ideal actions in a business context.

Simple examples: DIY faux hawks
Content strategy: Making sure users can easily access that coveted women’s guide to DIY fauxhawks on your catch-all women’s website. (Note: This particular example fails horribly. You have to click an inconspicuous button at the end of each example to go the next one, as opposed to being able to scan the entire ‘top 10’ list at once.)

Content marketing: A barber training website gives away free instructional content—in this case, a step-by-step text guide and video on how to create a faux hawk—in order to ultimately generate enrollments for an online barber training class and sales of DVDs. (This site is much more user-friendly than the first: Great content marketing AND strategy!)

 

how to cut hair

 

how to cut hair II

End the confusion
So, don’t be confused anymore if somebody starts throwing these popular terms at you, especially if it’s a recent graduate of this Northwestern course. Or, at the very least, you know which site to go to if you want the perfect DIY faux hawk.

Paul Richlovsky

About Paul Richlovsky

Paul brings a writing and teaching background to his decade-long marketing career. He advises clients on content strategy and editorial direction. He is an enthusiastic marketing automation practitioner and active member of the Cleveland Marketo User Group. He has written/edited multiple marketing guides, including those aimed at healthcare, higher education, financial services, B2C brands and manufacturing audiences. With a BA in English from the College of Wooster, he is also the author of a collection of poetry, "Under the Lunar Neon."He is particularly interested in usability, digital governance, ballroom dancing, bachata, racquet sports, and romping with his niece and nephews.

One Comment

  • mariadelaguardia says:

    Thanks for this! I’ve been following along the NU MOOC and creating an article series that applies the material to our clients, which are nonprofits. Now that I’ve gotten to week 5 (I’m a bit behind), it’s become clear to me that they are using “content strategy” to mean “content marketing.” In previous weeks it seemed to me that the issues discussed were applicable to both fields: understanding audiences, creating content that is meaningful and useful, and also usable based on platform, etc. After all, any IA or UX practitioner needs to know these same things about audiences before they begin a project; and there’s an overlap between content strategy and IA.

Leave a Reply